WHAT THE HELL! American Idol needs to hire Price Waterhouse to count votes because I don't believe Katharine McPhee won over both Chris and now Elliot. I prefered to see Elliot Yamin and Taylor Hicks duke it out, so to speak. In fact, if you caught the show tonight you'd have seen the tremendous support that both young men garnered when they returned to their respective home towns. The support and fan base is there. Geez!